Thomas was among the members of the Kitchen Irish who were called to the Burren Club for a meeting. Before the meeting began, Thomas organised an illegal dog fight using Max, only for Max to not be violent enough. Just as Thomas was chaining up Max after the fight, Nesbitt arrived and was growled at, leading to Thomas first apologising to the Irish leader before berating the dog for not showing that much aggression during the fight itself.
Once Max had been chained up, Thomas rejoined the rest of the Kitchen Irish members and and listened as Nesbitt gave a speech in which he claimed that it was time that the Kitchen Irish retook their place as the criminal leaders of New York City now that Wilson Fisk was locked away inside Ryker's Island. However as Nesbitt was speaking, a bullet fired by the Punisher hit the Irish leader in the forehead and killed him, before the room erupted in a hail of bullets. Thomas drew his gun and fired back but was quickly shot and killed with almost everyone else there.
- Punisher - Killer