Evaluating the Editing Events

Shabook·8/3/2015 in New on Marvel Cinematic Universe Wiki

Now that we had two different Weekly Editing Events, it is time to evaluate them in order to improve upcoming events. I'd like to ask you to spend a couple of minutes answering following questions with a response in this thread. To make them easy to read, please answer them in the same order they are written. Don't forget to add the # symbol in a new line with each response to automatically add the number.

These are the questions.

Have you participated in the events? If you haven't, why?
Do you consider them useful for the wiki?
Do you consider them to be fair?
Do you think the message announcing the event is clear enough?
Do you consider their rules to be too strict, restrictive or difficult to achieve?
What do you think of the awards?

Thank you in advance for your answers!

(Edited by Shabook)

Bratpack·8/3/2015

I participated in the first event, but not the second. I'm a writer, not a photographer, so my skills fit the first event.
Extremely; the amount of categories dropped dramatically.
Yes.
In the second one, yes. In the first one, maybe I did not understand the rules fully, but after a discussion, it was better. Also, it was the first one; trial and error makes things better.
No.
Fine by me.

(Edited by Bratpack)

1stAvenger·8/3/2015

Like Bratpack, I only participated in the first one, I am better at writing than at adding images.
Very much.
Yes.
Yes.
No.
I like them!

(Edited by 1stAvenger)

The Director of S.H.I.E.L.D.·8/3/2015

1. I have participated in both events.

2. Yes they are useful

3. I believe they are fair

4. Yes the message announcing the vent is clear enough

5. No the rules are fine

6. I like the awards. I also find them creative

(Edited by The Director of S.H.I.E.L.D.)

AKA S.I.H·8/3/2015

I have.
Yes I do.
Yes
Yes
No
I like the awards.

(Edited by AKA S.I.H)

Dr.Who1997·8/3/2015

I only participated in the second one. The reason for not participating in the first one is because I was busy with a real life thing.
I do, they are a great way to motivate people to edit more.
Uhh..yeah, why wouldn't I?
Yup, I can't think of a clearer way to tell people about it.
No, not really.
I think they are great.

(Edited by Dr.Who1997)

Professor Ambrius·8/3/2015

1. Yes. I took part in both events.

2. Yes. Like Dr.Who 1997 said, they're a great way to motivate people to edit and edit different articles they may not usually edit. I wouldn't have given a second thought to the Imageless articles if it hadn't been for that Edit Event.

3. Yes, they are fair.

4. Yes. But maybe make it a little bit clear if a certain events are needed to qualify for the event. I hadn't noticed that the last evented needed a total of 5 edits total till after I reread the rules a second time when I saw people listing their 5 selected articles.

5 No, not re.ally. About the only difficultly I had was finding an appropriate picture for the Imagless edit. There were just some people I couldn't find a picture of.

6. I like them. They're great.

(Edited by Professor Ambrius)

Shabook·8/3/2015

It would be very interesting that people who had nod participated evaluated the event, from the outside.

To the ones who have answered, thank you, I'll collect the answers as soon as possible.

(Edited by Shabook)

Greater good·8/5/2015

I have not participated in the events. I have been busy in real life and what time I have spent on this wiki recently has been dedicated to creating pages for actors (of which there were a lot).
Yes, they seem to have caused some big improvements.
Yes.
Yes.
No.
They're good.

(Edited by Greater good)

What do you think?